![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Пятнадцать лет назад: The authors apparently do not know what a divergent spectral sequence is
Фейсбучный постинг от 26 мая 2010 года -- https://www.facebook.com/posic/posts/pfbid0xfVVF5QDJMHx3BpMrQoLrzb3bBVSuu3V8TFdk9tRNLJxacft42DNXoMVDuSRuosJl :
"Finished with the book, now refereeing a paper. The authors apparently do not know what a divergent spectral sequence is. Will have to explain it to them -- not a pleasant task. Perhaps one shouldn't throw cold water on the enthusiasms of young men, but sometimes one has to. Spent the day trying to come up with a particularly impressive counterexample."
Сегодняшний комментарий к репосту в Фейсбуке:
There is no alternative to knowledge, to understanding. Care and caution are no good substitutes for lack of understanding. Some people do not know what a divergent spectral sequence is, other people do not know what a convergent spectral sequence is...
А вот копия ЖЖ-постинга от того же дня (26 мая 2010), где объясняется математическое содержание тогдашней проблемы с рецензируемой статьей -- https://posic.dreamwidth.org/410501.html
"Finished with the book, now refereeing a paper. The authors apparently do not know what a divergent spectral sequence is. Will have to explain it to them -- not a pleasant task. Perhaps one shouldn't throw cold water on the enthusiasms of young men, but sometimes one has to. Spent the day trying to come up with a particularly impressive counterexample."
Сегодняшний комментарий к репосту в Фейсбуке:
There is no alternative to knowledge, to understanding. Care and caution are no good substitutes for lack of understanding. Some people do not know what a divergent spectral sequence is, other people do not know what a convergent spectral sequence is...
А вот копия ЖЖ-постинга от того же дня (26 мая 2010), где объясняется математическое содержание тогдашней проблемы с рецензируемой статьей -- https://posic.dreamwidth.org/410501.html